Fresh Baked Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Classic cheese or create your own pizza.
$15.99
Gluten Free Pizza
Cheese & 1 item.
$14.99
Specialty Pizza
Sicilian Pizza
Oil, garlic, romano, tomatoes dipped in special sauce, onions & your choice of hot or sweet peppers & sausage or pepperoni.
$20.99
Spinach Ricotta Pizza
Spinach, mushrooms, garlic, ricotta, mozzarella & romano.
$20.99
Broccoli Cheddar Pizza
Melted cheddar, grated romano, onions, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano.
$20.99
White Pizza
Romano & mozzarella, onions, fresh cut tomatoes, 100% pure olive oil, garlic, pepper & oregano. Anchovies upon request.
$20.99
Taco Pizza
Hot, medium, or mild sauce with mozzarella, cheddar, ground beef, lettuce & tomatoes.
$20.99
Buffalo Style Pizza
Hot, medium, or mild diced chicken fingers, pizza sauce or blue cheese base & mozzarella.
$20.99
Veggie Deluxe Pizza
Mushrooms, sweet & hot peppers, green & black olives, onions & mozzarella.
$20.99
Spaghetti & Meatballs Parm Pizza
Pizza sauce, cooked spaghetti, chopped meatballs, mozzarella & romano.
$20.99
Hawaiian Pizza
Pizza sauce, ham, pineapple & mozzarella.
$20.99
Billy's 'ZAs
CBR Pizza
Chicken fingers, bacon, ranch, lite onion, mozzarella & cheddar.
$21.99
BBQ Chicken Pizza
BBQ sauce, chicken, bacon, cheddar, mozzarella & lite onions.
$21.99
Meat Lover's Deluxe Pizza
Pepperoni, sausage, meatball, ham & bacon.
$21.99
Steak Hoagie Pizza
Oil base hoagie cheese with a mixture of sweet peppers, mushrooms, onions & ribeye steak topped with romano & your choice of mozzarella or cheddar cheese.
$21.99
Supreme Deluxe Pizza
Our veggie deluxe topped with pepperoni & sausage.
$21.99
Grilled Chicken & Mushroom Pizza
Available with pizza sauce or white style topped with mozzarella cheese. Also great with broccoli!
$21.99
Stuffed Hot Pepper Pizza
Oil base, homemade cheese-filled hot banana peppers, topped with mozzarella & sausage.
$21.99
Chef Andrew's Alfredo Pizza
Alfredo sauce, broccoli, chicken, mozzarella & cheddar.
$21.99
Stinger Pizza
Hot, medium, or mild chicken fingers, oil base, ribeye steak, hoagie cheese & mozzarella.
$21.99
Greek Pizza
Oil base, tomatoes, black olives, hot peppers, chicken & feta topped with mozzarella or cheddar.
$21.99
Hitman Pizza
Oil base, sausage, capicola, salami, ham, sweet peppers, onions, hot peppers, hot sauce & mozzarella.
$21.99
Pizza by the Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice
$3.49
Peperoni Pizza Slice
$3.49
Every Day Combo Specials!
Mini Pak
Small pizza with cheese & one item plus 10 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings are available at an additional charge.
$32.99
Fab Pak
Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 10 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings are available at an additional charge.
$39.99
Special Pak
Large pizza with cheese & one item and double fingers with fries. Specialty sauce is available for an additional charge.
$49.99
Family Pak
Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 20 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available at additional charge.
$49.99
Super Pak
Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 30 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available at additional charge.
$62.99
Royal Pak
Large pizza with cheese & one item plus 50 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available at additional charge.
$75.99
Party Pak
Sheet pizza with cheese & one topping and 50 wings or boneless wings. Specialty wings available for an additional charge.
$89.99
Soups
Homemade Chili
$7.99
Homemade Chicken Noodle Soup
$7.99
Salads
Kevin's Catering Famous Strawberry Caesar Salad
Romaine, strawberries, blueberries, red onion & the famous dressing!
$13.99
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, celery, mozzarella cheese.
$7.99
Julienne Salad
Turkey, ham, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Antipasto Salad
Salami, ham, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, provolone & mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Tuna Salad
Tuna, lettuce, tomato, onion, celery & mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Taco Salad
Lettuce, tomato, hot pepper, black olives, taco meat, cheddar, mozzarella, salsa & sour cream.
$10.99
Greek Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot pepper, black olives, feta & Greek dressing.
$10.99
Grilled Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomato, onion, hot & sweet peppers, mushrooms, black & green olives, mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Chicken Finger Salad
Hot, medium or mild chicken, lettuce, tomato, celery, onions, cheddar & mozzarella.
$10.99
Turkey Club Salad
Lettuce, tomato, mozzarella, cheddar, turkey, and bacon.
$10.99
Side Orders
Bread Staches
Breadsticks flavored with garlic, butter & spices with a side of pizza sauce.
$5.99
Seasoned Curly Q Fries
$5.49
French Fries
Steak cut.
$5.49
Cheesy Fries
Nacho cheese.
$7.99
Poutine
Steak fries, gravy, topped with melted mozzarella.
$8.99
Onion Rings
$6.99
Battered Cauliflower
Served with dipping sauce.
$7.49
Battered Mushrooms
Served with dipping sauce.
$7.49
Battered Pickle Chips
Served with dipping sauce.
$7.49
Battered Broccoli Cheddar Bites
Served with dipping sauce.
$7.49
Deluxe Potato Skins
Skins with cheddar cheese, bacon, sour cream.
$9.99
Mac N Cheese
$9.99
Mozzarella Stix
Stix with spaghetti sauce.
$6.99
Pizza Logs
With pizza sauce.
$7.49
Jalapeno Poppers
Poppers with dipping sauce.
$6.99
Garlic Bread
$2.59
Garlic Bread with Mozzarella
$4.99
Garlic Bread with Tomatoes & Mozzarella
$5.49
Garlic Bread with Spinach & Mozzarella
$5.49
Chips
$1.59
Dipping Sauce
Hot sauce, blue cheese or ranch.
$1.29
Homemade Coleslaw
$2.99
Homemade Macaroni
$2.99
Homemade Potato Salad
$2.99
Salad Dressing
$0.99
Gravy
$2.49
Nachos with Cheese
Jalapenos on request.
$3.99
Nacho Cheese
$1.29
Jalapenos
$1.29
Salsa
$1.29
Chicken Wings
Chicken Wings
$16.99
Boneless Wings
Hot, medium, or mild. Served with bleu cheese and celery.
$15.99
Specialty Wings
Specialty Wings
Hot garlic parm, garlic parm, honey dijon, BBQ, cajun, extra hot, char-broiled BBQ, Italian gen Tso’s, mango habanero, sweet chili, sriracha, teriyaki, hot BBQ, Chiavetta's, A.1 wing sauce.
$18.99
Chicken Fingers
Chicken Fingers
Hot, medium or mild served with bleu cheese and celery. Specialty sauces available for an additional cost.
$17.99
Chicken Fingers with Fries
Hot, medium or mild served with bleu cheese and celery. Specialty sauces available for an additional cost.
$18.99
Calzones & Stromboli
Pizza Roll
Large dough stuffed with pepperoni, sausage, sweet peppers, mozzarella & a side of pizza sauce.
$21.99
Calzone
Up to 3 items. Dough filled with mozzarella and ricotta cheese served with a side of spaghetti or pizza sauce.
$16.99
Stromboli
Mozzarella, pepperoni, sweet peppers & ham wrapped in dough with a side of sauce. No substitutions.
$15.99
Deli Sandwiches
Roast Beef Sandwich
$9.99
Ham Sandwich
$7.99
Corned Beef Sandwich
$8.99
Turkey Sandwich
Oven-roasted.
$8.99
Capicola Sandwich
$8.99
Hard Salami Sandwich
$7.99
Cheese Sandwich
$7.99
Tuna Sandwich
$8.99
Hot Sandwiches
Steak & Cheese Sandwich
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$11.99
Chicken Finger Sandwich
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$11.99
B.L.T. Sandwich
A lot of bacon!
$10.99
Turkey Club
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$10.99
Chicken Breast Fillet Sandwich
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$10.99
Fried Bologna Sandwich
American cheese & sauteed onions.
$8.99
Fish Sandwich
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$10.99
Italian Sausage Sandwich
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$10.99
Cheeseburger Sandwich
With lettuce & tomatoes.
$10.99
Roast Beef Sandwich
With gravy.
$11.99
Turkey Sandwich
With gravy.
$11.99
Hot Capicola & Cheese Sandwich
$9.99
Beef on Weck Sandwich
$10.99
Submarines
Roast Beef Sub
Our own slow oven-roasted.
$9.99
Tuna Sub
$8.99
Corned Beef Sub
$8.99
Ham Sub
$7.99
Turkey Sub
Oven-roasted.
$8.99
Ham & Turkey Sub
$8.99
Italian Assorted Sub
Hard salami, capicola & ham.
$8.99
Ham, Turkey & Roast Beef Sub
$9.99
Capicola Sub
$8.99
Hard Salami Sub
$7.99
Cheese Sub
$7.99
Bologna Sub
$7.99
Hot Submarines
The "Statche" Sub
Steak, hot stuffed peppers, lettuce & tomato or fried mushrooms & onions.
$13.99
"Stinger" Sub
Steak, chicken finger, lettuce & tomato.
$12.99
"Bully" Sub
Steak, sausage, lettuce & tomato.
$12.99
Steak & Cheese with Fried Peppers & Onions Sub
$11.99
Steak & Cheese with Fried Mushrooms & Onions Sub
$11.99
Steak & Cheese with Lettuce & Tomato Sub
$11.99
Steak & Spinach Sub
Lettuce, tomato or fried peppers & onions.
$11.99
Chicken & Spinach Sub
Lettuce & tomato or fried peppers & onions.
$11.99
Hitman's Delight Sub
Fried hot & sweet peppers, onions, italian sausage, ham, salami, capicola, cheese & hot sauce.
$11.99
Baked Reuben Sub
Corned beef, kraut, swiss cheese, thousand island dressing.
$11.99
Rib Sub
Rib, bbq sauce, mozzarella cheese.
$10.99
Royale Sub
Italian sausage & capicola, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Italian Sausage Sub
Lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Fish Sub
Battered haddock, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Cheeseburger Sub
3/4 lb. Of black angus, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Cheeseburger Royale Sub
3/4 lb. Of black angus, ham, cheese, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Bacon Cheeseburger Sub
Lettuce & tomato.
$11.99
Baked Roast Beef Sub
Lettuce, tomato & mozzarella or cheddar.
$11.99
Roast Beef Classic Sub
Our garlic bread with mushrooms & mozzarella.
$11.99
Pizza Sub
Pepperoni, mozzarella & pizza sauce.
$10.99
White Pizza Sub
Just like our White Pizza.
$10.99
Veal Parmesan Sub
Veal, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
$10.99
Sausage Parmesan Sub
Italian sausage, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
$10.99
Meatball Parmesan Sub
Meatballs, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
$10.99
Chicken Parmesan Sub
Chicken, spaghetti sauce, mozzarella.
$11.99
Eggplant Parmesan Sub
5-6 pieces of eggplant, spaghetti sauce, and mozzarella.
$10.99
Chicken Finger Sub
Provolone & bleu cheese, lettuce & tomato.
$11.99
BLT Sub
A lot of bacon! Lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Chicken Cordon Bleu Sub
Chicken, ham, Swiss cheese, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Turkey Club Sub
Turkey, bacon, cheese, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Grilled Chicken Sub
Lettuce & tomato - try with BBQ or dijon. Extra for bacon and ham.
$10.99
California Dream Sub
Chicken breast, bacon, swiss, ranch, lettuce & tomato.
$10.99
Tuna Cheddar Melt Sub
Tuna, lettuce, cheddar & tomato.
$10.99
Piglet Sub
Sausage, ham, bacon, lettuce & tomato.
$11.99
Fried Bologna Sub
American cheese & sauteed onions.
$10.99
Super Hoagies
Super Steak Hoagie
$12.99
Super Sausage Hoagie
$12.99
Super Steak & Sausage Hoagie
$14.99
Super Turkey Hoagie
$12.99
Super Chicken Hoagie
$12.99
Super Cheeseburger Hoagie
Try adding lettuce & tomato.
$12.99
Wraps
Ham Wrap
$8.99
Assorted Wrap
$8.99
Turkey Wrap
$8.99
Capicola Wrap
$8.99
Hard Salami Wrap
$8.99
Tuna Wrap
$8.99
Vegetable Wrap
$8.99
Turkey Club Wrap
$10.99
Steak Wrap
$10.99
Chicken Breast Wrap
$10.99
Chicken Finger Wrap
$10.99
Greek Wrap
Chicken breast, feta, black olives, hot banana peppers & greek dressing.
$10.99
Beef On Weck Wrap
Roast beef, horsey sauce, pepper jack, pretzel salt & caraway seeds.
$10.99
Stinger Wrap
Steak and chicken finger.
$11.99
Tacos & Pastelitos
Ground Beef Taco
$6.99
Chicken Taco
$9.99
Steak Taco
$9.99
Chicken Finger Taco
$9.99
Roast Beef Taco
$9.99
Steak Fajita Burrito
Fried sweet peppers & onions, cheddar & sub cheese.
$9.99
Chicken Fajita Burrito
Fried sweet peppers & onions, cheddar & sub cheese.
$9.99
Stinger Taco
Steak & chicken finger.
$11.99
Pastelitos
Beef & cheese.
$3.99
Mac & Cheese
Mac & Cheese
$8.99
Dinners
Stuffed Hot Banana Peppers
Peppers on garlic points.
$15.99
Bar-B-Que Ribs
Includes coleslaw, fries & roll.
$17.99
Grilled Chicken Dinner
Boneless chicken breast, salad & fries.
$14.99
Cheese Ravioli
Jumbo ravioli, two meatballs & garlic bread.
$14.99
Stuffed Shells
Jumbo shells, two meatballs & garlic bread.
$14.99
Spaghetti
With two meatballs & garlic bread.
$14.99
Spaghetti Parmesan
Two meatballs, mozzarella & garlic bread.
$14.99
Eggplant Parmesan
Breaded eggplant, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.
$14.99
Veal Parmesan
Breaded veal, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.
$14.99
Chicken Parmesan
Breaded chicken, spaghetti, mozzarella & garlic bread.
$14.99
Baked Penne
Penne pasta, mozzarella & garlic bread.
$14.99
Fish Dinner
Two pieces of haddock fish, salad & fries.
$14.99
Shrimp Dinner
Breaded butterfly shrimp with fries & cocktail sauce.
$14.99
Roast Beef With Gravy Dinner
Served on Costanzo's roll with gravy, salad & fries.
$14.99
Turkey With Gravy Dinner
Served on Costanzo's roll with gravy, salad & fries.
$14.99
Beef on Weck Dinner
Served with salad and fries.
$14.99
Desserts
Cookies
Huge! Chocolate chips, peanut butter, oatmeal raisin, macadamia nut & white chocolate.
$2.49
Iced Lemon Loaf Cake
$4.99
Chocolate Banana Swirl Loaf Cake
$4.99
Iced Pumpkin Swirl Loaf Cake
$4.99
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
$4.99
Brownie
Gluten free.
$4.99
Salted Caramel Brownie
$4.99
Belgium Waffle
$4.99
Apple Pie Logs
With caramel sauce dip.
$7.99
Beverages
Soda
Coke products.
$2.79
Flavored Iced Tea
$2.89
Powerade
$2.89
Monster Energy Drink
$3.99
Red Bull
$3.99
Water
$1.99
Slush Puppie
$1.50
Every Day Lunch Specials!
1/2 Cold Sub Lunch
Plus pop or french fries.
$10.49
1/2 Hot Sub Lunch
Plus pop or french fries.
$11.49
Large Beef Taco Lunch
Plus pop or french fries.
$8.99
Two Pizza Slices Lunch
Plus pop or french fries.
$8.99
5 Wings Lunch
Plus pop or french fries.
$10.99
Subs & Wraps Catering
Sub Platter Catering
$59.99
Wrap Platter Catering
$59.99
Mustachio's Pizzeria
Welcome to Mustachio's Pizzeria - the right place for a delicious pizza in Buffalo, NY! We're a local restaurant where the food is fresh, the service friendly, and all the customers - satisfied. With that in mind, we joyfully invite you to join us for a hot slice, here in Erie County. As you may expect, pizza is our specialty, and we offer a great selection on our menu. For a start, you can try our cheese and gluten-free pie, or even create yours and choose the toppings you prefer. In addition, we serve a number of specialty pies such as our Sicilian, Veggie Deluxe, Taco, and Hawaiian, to name a few. Plus, you can try our so-called Billy's 'ZAs pizzas, as well as our pizza by the slice. Of course, all of these taste amazing so you cannot go wrong with whatever you get. But hey, we're more than just a pizza place. In fact, we serve numerous tasty salads, wings, calzones, sandwiches, submarines, dinners, desserts, and more. Also, we provide awesome lunch specials that are available between 11 AM and 3 PM. Feel free to join us for a pleasant meal with your family and friends. Our dedicated staff is eager to serve you, and we promise you won't be disappointed. Or you can always order us for pickup or delivery through Slice!
Full Hours